Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

Link to this comparison view

Both sides previous revisionPrevious revision
Next revision
Previous revision
debunking-desistance [2025/12/29 02:42] valahdebunking-desistance [2025/12/29 15:50] (current) – [What Modern Research Actually Shows] valah
Line 113: Line 113:
 **Compare the populations:** **Compare the populations:**
  
-Population Time Period Dysphoria Criteria Socially Transitioned Persistence Rate +Population Time Period Dysphoria Criteria Socially Transitioned Persistence Rate ^
-|---|---|---|---|---|+
 | **Early desistance studies** | 1970s-1990s | DSM-III/IV (no distress requirement) | No | ~20% | | **Early desistance studies** | 1970s-1990s | DSM-III/IV (no distress requirement) | No | ~20% |
 | **Trans Youth Project** | 2010s-2020s | Modern standards | Yes | 92.7% | | **Trans Youth Project** | 2010s-2020s | Modern standards | Yes | 92.7% |
Line 250: Line 249:
 ===== Bottom Line ===== ===== Bottom Line =====
  
-Claim Reality +Claim Reality ^
-|-------|---------|+
 | "60-90% of trans kids desist" | These studies examined gender-nonconforming children, 83% of whom didn't meet dysphoria criteria | | "60-90% of trans kids desist" | These studies examined gender-nonconforming children, 83% of whom didn't meet dysphoria criteria |
 | "Intensity doesn't predict persistence" | The studies themselves show intensity strongly predicts persistence | | "Intensity doesn't predict persistence" | The studies themselves show intensity strongly predicts persistence |
Line 270: Line 268:
 The "desistance" narrative relies on conflating gender-nonconformity with gender dysphoria and comparing incomparable eras. When the actual evidence is examined closely, it supports gender-affirmative care, not caution about affirmation. The "desistance" narrative relies on conflating gender-nonconformity with gender dysphoria and comparing incomparable eras. When the actual evidence is examined closely, it supports gender-affirmative care, not caution about affirmation.
  
----+
  
 ====== References ====== ====== References ======
Print/export
QR Code
QR Code debunking-desistance (generated for current page)